The Best Ever Apple Pie Cookies

11th August 2018
Blog post

I have to admit, creating a recipe for the perfect gluten & dairy free cookie was tough. I wanted the kind of cookies you get from the fresh bakery section at the supermarket – gooey, almost caramelly middles & crunchy edges. Its taken me a longggg time to get a fool-proof recipe but I’m finally there – THE BEST EVER COOKIES!!!! And what’s more, they are ridiculously easy to make. So… you guys who say “oh, I’m rubbish at baking, it always goes wrong!”, bet you can make these 😉

You only need

*5 simple ingredients

*A wooden spoon/spatula

*Follow my 10 steps!

Mine are Apple Pie flavour but you could add anything you like to the base.

I made a batch with chunks of marzipan in for my dads Fathers day presents and they went down a treat. Enjoy!!

The Best Ever Apple Pie Cookies

After LOADS of practise, I’ve finally developed a fool proof cookie recipe & it was too good not to share!! These are apple pie flavoured but you could add anything you like – choc chip, white choc and cranberry, what are you going to have?!
Prep Time10 minutes
Cook Time15 minutes
Total Time25 minutes
Servings: 14 large cookies
Course: Dessert, Snack
Cuisine: American, english
Keyword: apple pie, biscuits, cookies


Cookie Base

  • 315 grams plain flour
  • 120 grams Stork - comes in block, wrapped in paper
  • 90 grams caster sugar
  • 110 grams light brown sugar
  • 1 egg

Optional Flavourings

  • 3 generous pinches Apple pie flavourings - if you havent got a ready made mix use ginger, cinnamon, cardamon
  • 1 eating apple


  • Melt the butter – I’m lazy so I do this in a frying pan, on a very very low heat! You could also do it in the microwave or over a bain-marie.
  • Pour the butter into a mixing bowl with caster and light brown sugar and mix with a wooden spoon/spatula until fully combined. Should take about a minute.
  • Crack the egg into the same bowl. Mix together until just combined. Set aside.
  • Add the flour to butter/sugar mixture & stir until fully combined. 
    >Note – It will look like a lot of flour! Keep stirring and it'll all come together. Promise!
  • Add your favourite flavourings (chocolate chips, apple pie flavourings etc). If youre making apple pie cookies, just add the spices – you’ll be adding the apple in a sec! 
  • Cover with cling film and place into the fridge for at least an hour
  • Remove from the fridge and divide into 14 balls – about meatball size. If you’re making apple pie cookies, add small cubes of apple to each ball (I go for about 5 cubes in each). The mixture should not be sticky at this stage. 
    What to do if it is sticky – rub a bit more flour into the mix until it feels like the stickiness has gone away. I suggest 1tbsp of flour at a time. Return to the fridge for another 10mins to firm up and start this step again!
  • Place onto baking parchment on a baking tray, leaving lots of room around them. Put into the oven for 12-15mins at 175oC until the edges are browning but the middles are still gooey
  • Leave to cool on the baking tray for at least 10-15mins before attempting to move them – they are VERY fragile when warm but they harden up once they start to cool


Butter Substitute: Dairy is probably the toughest substitution in any baking recipe. I’ve tried a couple of different options (spreadable butters, lard, etc) and the best thing for this recipe is “Stork”. Its a slab of butter, not the spreadable tub & only costs 80p in most supermarkets.  Heres what it looks like:
You can keep the cookie dough mixture in the fridge for up to 7 days – some say it actually gets better with age too as the flavours develop!
Print Recipe

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating

Prev Post Next Post
%d bloggers like this: